Am 
22.12.2014 17:17, schrieb Guyé André: 
  
  [...] 
  
 
  I agree with you, Mal. For DX, the Propagation on both MF 
  BANDS 160 and 630 meters similar. The only diference is the ERP power, because 
  on 630 m the standard ham antennas have not 100 % of efficiency, 
  HI.
 
  
  
  Propagation on both MF BANDS similar
  de MAL/G3KEV
  
Never ever! I saw regular 
WSPR decodes with 2W TX power (if it is true!) on 160m between EU and VK. No 
chance on 630m except some  very very very very very very very very very 
very very very very very very very very very very very very very very very very 
very very very very very very rare events like prooved by F6CNI :-)
I've put 
out several 10000 WSPR sequences now, with decent power. Best distances were to 
the US east coast, TF, EA, upper LA and near Moscow. Not a single one above 
2500km over land.
And most amateur antennas are not 100% efficient on 160m as 
well. But 1W ERP is possible on MF for most i assume. In more than 2 years we 
saw now that WSPR from EU does not propagate farer than 2000 km, except some TA 
detections, i.e. mostly water on the path. However it is a challenge to leave 
detections in 2000 km over land. And Japan is about 9000 km over land, from 
here, or France or UK.
So let's hope for the very rare events. Better try LF 
instead, no choke :-)
73, Stefan